The Resurrection of Jesus Christ, as God’s Firstfruits Fulfilled, in 2024

EASTER and PENTECOST in the Bible

 

The Resurrection of Jesus Christ, as God’s First-fruits Fulfilled,

And Pentecost, as Weeks Fulfilled

Among Jews and Christians (Jewish and Gentile)

Larry N. Baker


     Among the biblical Jewish Holydays that the Church commemorated and continues to commemorate in the New Testament, Resurrection Sunday of Easter (and its Good Friday connection) and Pentecost are the only two. In the Bible these two are both specifically tied to the Jewish Holydays of Passover and Unleavened Bread, respectively as First-fruits and Weeks [Pentecost]. To be specific, these two Holydays, both coming after Passover and Unleavened Bread, are on the first and seventh Sundays following Passover: First-fruits [Easter Resurrection Sunday] and Weeks [Pentecost Sunday]. They are respectively called in Hebrew “Bikkurim” and then “Shavuot.” Since the date of Passover with Unleavened Bread is specified in Exodus 12:6 and 18 in what comes to be the 15th of Nisan with preparation on the 14th of Nisan, then Easter and Pentecost would come after Nisan 15. Thus, it behooves Christians who are using the Gregorian Calendar to find on their calendar each year the specific date and time of the 15th of Nisan in order to find both Easter Sunday, as the Resurrection of Jesus Christ, and Pentecost Sunday, as the Birthday of The Church, seven weeks later.

     Such “holydays” were described by Paul, as “a shadow of things to come” in that they had a prophetic fulfillment in the Resurrection Christ and later in the decent of the Holy Spirit on Pentecost Sunday in Acts 2. These “holydays” do have a shadowing point to the yet-future things in “The Day of the LORD.” Paul explained in Colossians 2:16-17 about warnings of legalism in the celebrations of “a new moon or sabbath.” However, their remembrance and study provide times of instruction in their prophetic fulfillment for Christ and the Church, “Therefore, have no one judge you in food or in drink or on the part of a festival or a new moon or sabbath which things are a shadow of things to come, but the body is of Christ.” So then, we need not have anyone tell how we are right or wrong in what you eat or drink or how we celebrate various holydays, even the monthly and weekly holydays. These rules are a preview of the future Messianic Millennial Kingdom that will be the latter part of The Day of the LORD, however our present focus is on the Church, as the Body of Christ. Such study behooves us to learn and take the Bible seriously.

     To begin with the Hebrews have a “Lunisolar Calendar” tied to one specific Solar Event each year, namely the Spring Equinox. This is in contrast to the popular “fully Solar Calendar” of our Gregorian Calendar and the “fully Lunar Calendar” of Islam, (although the traditional Chinese Calendar is also lunisolar, somewhat similar to the Hebrew Calendar but with its first month of the year shifted two months earlier).  No matter how far one goes back in time or forward into time, the nice consistency of the Hebrew Calendar over the centuries has easily allowed for an exact and quite simple replication year after year, even for some 35 centuries, without extensive “retooling” of the calendar but only having a “Leap Month” every few years. The key to this concept of calendar is that the sun and the moon according to Genesis 1:14-16 were created to set “seasons” – fixed times – for agricultural…and celebrations.


THE SEVEN HOLYDAYS OF ISRAEL IN LEVITICUS 23


     Moses specified Seven Annual Jewish “Holydays” in Leviticus 23. The Spring Holydays are specifically in Leviticus 23:4-22, along with Exodus 12:2-6.  As to a simple summation of above, these four Spring Holydays appear on the Hebrew Calendar every year this way:

Since the First New Moon of Spring is the 1st of Nisan –

1)    Pesach - Passover’s First Day is the 15th of Nisan.

Pesach Week of 7 more days is the 16th through 21st of Nisan.

2)    Matza - Unleavened Bread is also the 15th of Nisan.

3)    Biblical Bikkurim - First-fruits is the Yom Rishon [Sunday] of the 16th through 23rd of Nisan.

[or Rabbinic Bikkurim - First-fruits is the 16th of Nisan.]

4)    Biblical Shavu‘ot – Pentecost is the Yom Rishon [Sunday] of 7th through 13th Sivan.

[or Rabbinic Shavu‘ot – Pentecost is the 6th through 7th of Sivan.]

     Each year the Biblical New Year’s Day comes and goes often with little notice or fanfare among most Jews and Gentiles alike. Every year the 1st of Abib [Nisan] always comes on the First New Moon after the Spring Equinox. But this year in 2024 for this to happen there was a need for adding a “Leap Month” called Veadar/Adar II, as a 13th month, to the Jewish calendar. The last day of Veadar/Adar II ended at sunset on April 8. Notably there was a Total Solar Eclipse visible across the Heartland of the U.S. on Monday afternoon, April 8, from 1:30 pm CDT in Texas through 2:30 pm CDT in Maine [3:30 EDT]. Of course, a total eclipse is always during the phase of a New Moon, but this specific one was a Totally Dark New Moon with no sliver of light, as is often in other New Moons. Even to be more specific, this North American Total Solar Eclipse occurred at the very point of time that was about two hours after sunset into the beginning of the 1st night and then 1st day of Nisan in Jerusalem – the First Month of the Jewish Year! So, according to Exodus 12:2 this day would be a BIBLICAL NEW’S YEARS DAY in Jerusalem – “Shana Tovah!”   See Exodus 12:2; 13:3-4; 23:15-16.

     Exactly two weeks after this 1st day of Nisan is The Day of Passover beginning at sunset April 22 through sunset April 23 which was celebrated by Jesus in The Last Supper with His apostles. Passover continues to be celebrated for 7 days with an 8th day traditionally added [Nisan 15-22 = April 23-30] (according to Leviticus 23:4-5). Passover was not only the day of Jesus’ crucifixion but was to be fulfilled prophetically in the very crucifixion and death of Jesus Christ on the Cross. 

     Over the millennia gone by there have been two popular interpretations of Lev. 23:11, 15-16 regarding First-fruits and Pentecost exactly 7 weeks later:

1)    Rabbinic Judaism and many Messianic congregations take the “Sabbath” in Lev. 23:11, as a special “High Sabbath” following Unleavened Bread and thus have Bikkurim/First-fruits always on the 17th of Nisan every year, and the “Sabbath” in Lev. 23:15-16, as subsequent weekly Sabbaths, for determining Shavuot/Pentecost exactly seven weeks later.

2)    Some Messianic congregations simply take “Sabbath” in Lev. 23:11, as simply the weekly Sabbath, as it is in Lev. 23:15-16, and thus have Bikkurim/First-fruits always on the Sunday after Unleavened Bread and Shavuot/Pentecost exactly seven weeks later.

     So, then, if one follows the second view, the Sunday following the First Day of Passover, that is, April 28 (beginning sunset April 27), will be the Celebration of First-fruits, as Easter Sunday. It was on this Holyday that Jesus rose from the dead, as popularly called Easter, if one takes a rather natural and literal interpretation of Leviticus 23:11-16 regarding the word, “Sabbath(s)”, as simply the “Weekly Sabbath.” To be precise First-fruits, the day after the weekly Sabbath, was prophetically pointing to The Resurrection of Jesus Christ that is in 2024 would be celebrated April 28 (specifically after sunset April 27), (where Palm Sunday of the Triumphal Entry would be on April 21 and Good Friday would then be on April 26 and Maundy Thursday would then be either on April 25, traditionally, or the first evening of Passover on April 22, to be more specific biblically).

     Then, Seven Weeks after First-fruits on Sunday, June 16 (beginning sunset June 15) will be “Pentecost Sunday” according to Leviticus 23:15-16. This Holyday of “Weeks” is also thus on the first day of the week, Sunday, and according to Acts 2:1ff.


FIRSTFRUITS AND PENTECOST WITH THE DEVELOPMENT OF AN INCIPIENT ANTISEMITISM AND ANTICHRISTIANITY


     To broaden all of this picture, there are four methods of determining the Date of Easter (and hence Pentecost) each year. Some years two or three or all four may coincide on the same Sunday. So, since Passover with Unleavened Bread in 2024 begins at sunset April 22, for various reasons in their various traditions these are the dates for Easter and Pentecost:

1)    The Western Roman Churches (Roman Catholic & Protestant) have Easter on March 31 (ignoring the 1st of Nisan) and then having Pentecost on May 19.

2)    Some Messianic Churches have Easter, as Bikkurim, on April 28 and then Pentecost, as Shavuot, on June 16. [This seems more biblical.]

3)    Though, many Messianic Churches follow the Rabbinic traditions popular among Jews and have their counterpart to “Easter,” as their Bikkurim, on April 24, and then Pentecost, called Shavuot, on June 12-13.

4)    The Eastern Orthodox Churches have Easter, as Pascha [the Greek word for “Passover”] on May 5 (though to be after Passover but ignoring the Gregorian Calendar) and then Pentecost on June 23.


     Calculating the date for Easter each year was instituted by the early church fathers in the fourth century AD, where the Council of Nicaea set the date for Easter that was not to follow “the custom of the Jews” in connection with to their dating of their Passover. After this a consensus of the Western [Roman] Church was that Easter would be simply the Sunday following the full moon following the Spring equinox (with no accounting of that month’s new moon either before or after the Spring Equinox, as done among the Jews). The Spring Equinox was determined to always be a specific point of time somewhere in March 19 through 21, and its following full moon was determined to be 14 days after the start of what the Western Church calls its “ecclesiastical” new moon. The point is that this new moon may be either BEFORE OR AFTER the Spring Equinox. There is disagreement between the Roman Catholic churches and the Eastern Orthodox churches on these issues, which has led to them observing different dates for Easter Sunday only about 75% of the time. The early church at the Council of Nicaea set the date for determining Easter with a little animosity toward the Jews and their Passover, such that they had no interest in connecting Easter to Passover (which will be the middle of April in 2024r). Their “Ecclesiastical Full Moon” did not have to be the same, as the “Pascal Full Moon” (i.e., their Ecclesiastical Month was not necessarily Nisan).

     In other words, their “ecclesiastical” new moon and full moon had no need of coinciding with the Jewish month of Nisan with its “Pascal” moon and full. The determining of the date for Easter was done with no relationship to how the date for the Jewish Passover was determined. In the fourth century AD the church in the Roman Empire made a conscious decision to divorce itself from anything Jewish. The Old Testament’s appointed times of Passover and the Feast of Unleavened Bread were no longer necessary to them.

It is interesting how the Western Roman Catholic Church tradition of Easter ignores the date of Passover in determining Easter, where the Eastern Orthodox Churches work with Easter, as following the Jewish Passover. It is especially odd, when the King James Version of the Bible translated “Pascha” [Aramaic then Greek word for Passover] in Acts 12:2, as “Easter,” when most other translations use “Passover” [as they and the King James Version do in all other places in the Greek New Testament where “Pascha” occurs]. The Church in the 17th century understood this connection. However, this may reflect an incipient antisemitism within the Church that continued at times subtle and at times overt, beginning in the early 4th century (with the Roman Empire giving Christianity first legal status and then priority status, where the Church and Judaism were no longer having to “team up” against pagan Roman Empire anymore). Sadly this has continued on through to the 20th century in the middle of which the Jews were given their nationhood in the Land of Israel. Sadly, such an incipient antisemitism within the Church has produced an insipid Christianity.


THE DIVERGENCE OF CHRISTIANITY (GENTILES AND JEWS) AND RABBINIC JUDAISM HAS ONLY GROWN.


      In other words, most Christian churches, especially in the West, today see themselves metaphorically but unknowingly, much as “cut flowers” severed from anything Jewish rather than as being “potted plants” with a “Hebraic rootage” of heritage. Such churches, as cut flowers, can be awkwardly shortsighted in their ignoring of their Hebrew roots, but other churches, as potted plants, can be broadly farsighted in seeing and appreciating their Hebrew roots in the Old Testament. The former have somewhat of an awkward understanding of the Old Testament, where the latter have a more traditional and literal understanding of the Old Testament. 

     Tyler Dawn Rosenquist in her book, The Bridge: Crossing Over Into the Fullness of Covenant Life, has an interesting Messianic observation and illustration of this Christian-Messianic-Judaic tension in Christian church/congregations and Synagogues: “To me, knowing the history of the fourth century CE – that Rome forcibly legislated the removal of Christians out of the synagogues and Torah keepers out of the assemblies of Messiah – Christians celebrating Christmas and Easter seem very much like children celebrating the consequences of having a broken home. Without the Christians, the Jews lost their Messiah and without the Jews, the Christians lost their inheritance. It’s like a child celebrating the absence of a parent who wasn’t even a bad parent. Christmas and Easter happened because of a broken home, and that grieves me – it doesn’t make me want to celebrate. At one point all believers in Yeshua were called Nazarene Jews, for hundreds of years – Rome robbed us of a stable home life.””

     There appears to have been a “mutual Messianic Divergence” between Rabbinic Judaism and the Christian Church in an incipient AntiSemitism in the Church and AntiChristianized among the Jews occurring in the fourth century, as the Roman Empire became Christianized, and even a continued development of both over the centuries since. Some churches moderated this in their zeal for evangelism among the Jews; and some Jews moderated this, as they found Yeshua/Jesus, as their Messiah and Savior.  Such was the earlier development of Messianic congregations, quite small in number over the centuries. They did find a biblical faith in Yeshua/Jesus and an interesting place within the Christian Church. This was more apparent in the early Church. However, Rabbinic Judaism did react and sought to avoid any special observance of “Yom Rishon” (Sunday) by reacting to an ancient interpretation of “Sabbath” in Lev. 23:11, 15-16, as being the “weekly Sabbath” and put Firstfruits as the third day of Passover Week regardless of the day of the week. On the other hand, the Church avoided Hebrew Calendar Months and Feast Holydays, except for Easter and Pentecost. Over the centuries this sad fracture between Gentile Christians and Jews (who are outside of a faith in Christ) has grown. 

     It seems that Jews outside of any faith in Christ have reacted both to the Church’s replacing of the Sabbath with Sunday and to sporadic antisemitism by Gentiles in the Church. Many Gentile Christians have reacted to a Judaic meticulosity of adherence to Torah-legalism found in the Law of Moses along with sporadic cultural snobbery at times found in Judaism.


CHRISTIANITY AND RABBINIC JUDAISM HAVE COMMON ROOTS


     However, both groups, traditional Judaism (especially Conservative and Orthodox) and biblical Christianity, do generally agree on many things in life and culture, such as –

1)    The importance of the “Tanach” – Old Testament – as God’s revelation within Israel.

2)    The God of Abraham and Isaac and Jacob, as Jehovah, with Jesus being Jewish.

3)    A common Judeo-Christian moral code of right living found within the Bible.

4)    The serious prioritizing of covenants, life, marriage, children, family, loyalty, love and patriotism.

5)    A weekly gathering of the faithful for prayer, worship, and instruction.

6)    The importance of personal freedoms within democratic republics and capitalistic free-market economies.

7)    A fair and honest judicial system.

8)    The evil of both antisemitism and anti-Christianism.

9)    The support for the nation-state of Israel.

10) The eschewing of globalism.

11) The future judgment and Messianic glory of the Day of the LORD yet to come.

12) Periodic various commemorative dates of religious and spiritual importance.

13) A variety of “hyphenated” Jews-Christians organizations in philanthropy, common community interests, political interests, and scholarship.

14) Earlier American founders finding the “Hebrew Republic” in the Bible, as a model for founding the American Republic and offering religious freedom to Jews.

15) Being a preserved possession of God for a special purpose for His use on earth.

16) A sense of “connection” of one group with the other.


     Paul was very clear in his Gospel Presentation of his book to the Romans, when he specifically repeated three times “to the Jew first, but also to the Greek” in 1:16; 2:9-10. Then he declared in Romans 3:2, “…for first indeed that they were committed with the sayings of God.” A notable hallmark of the Book of Acts is the transition from The Age of Israel to The Age of the Church. This transition can be traced through all the chapters of Acts which began with the question in Acts 2, “How do Gentiles fit into The Church?” and end with the question in Acts 28, “How to Jews fit into The Church?” So, “How do the Gentiles fit in?” In Acts the Church expands to include Gentile believers. Here in Acts 11:19 the Church is still hesitant to understand this concerning Cornelious. But finally in Acts 15, the “watershed chapter” of Acts, Luke describes the Jerusalem Council of Apostles, that dealt with “the Gentile-issue” – they were to be received in full fellowship with just four things listed in Acts 15:20 and 29 (regarding demonic, health, and fornication matters).  The rest of Acts expands upon the growth of the Church to include Gentiles to the point that the Jews in Rome appear to pose a problem in Acts 28:24-29 and visited with Paul in how they are to be a part of the Church. Some believed and become a part. But some did not believe and thus having no part in the Church. So, ends the Book of Acts with “How do the Jews fit in?”  Such has been the case until our present day. 

     In our current situation Messianic Jews and some Christian Gentiles seek to bridge this gap. Messianic Israelis and Arab-Christian Israelis, as well as various Middle Eastern Christians outside of Israel, have a geographical opportunity to work together, as bridges.

Christians both Gentile and Messianic around the world have an opportunity to come together in those bridges and encourage Jews and Jewish converts of traditional Judaism. Christianity and Judaism both share a sense of being a preserved possession of God for a special purpose for His use on earth in the notion of being a “peculiar people.” This somewhat explains the historic support of the nation of Israel by America and the Christian West and Christians around the world.

     Gentile Christians might do well to find opportunities to at least commemorate, rather than celebrate, The Seven Feast Days of Leviticus 23, and remember them each year. Jews within traditional Judaism might to well to find opportunities to commemorate, rather than celebrate, the historical Jesus, as Yeshua, and remember various Christian events through the year.

     Those in Christianity and Judaism see that there is more that unites us than divide us, in contrast to all other religions and (pagan) cultures around the world. Throughout history Jewish people have always found protection within Christian nations that take the Bible seriously, and Christian nations have been blessed by God in their protecting of Jewish people with secured rights.


THE COMING DAY OF THE LORD


     The Bible prophesies about a future “Day of the LORD” – A Day of Yahweh – when Israel will be back in the Land, their land, with an understanding the Jesus Christ, their Yeshua HaMashiach, much as the Church had taught before they are taken to heaven, when this Day begins. This will be a future time, when the Last Three Holydays in the fall, when the Feasts of Trumpets, Atonement, and Tabernacles will be historically fulfilled. Anything of any kind of antisemitism in the Church will be totally gone. However, for a brief seven years the lost around the world will mount a time of antisemitism greater than any time before in history. But God will place within the hands of that future Israel His “Stewardship of Evangelism” to take the “gospel of the kingdom” around the world for the end to come just before the beginning of the Messianic Kingdom Age of Christ for 1,000 years!

Share by: